|
Reviews Archive
Book Reviews
Shades of Grey: Jasper FForde
 Eccentric characters, quirky, complex plot; part mystery, part romance, unnervingly sinister and definitely odd, Shades of Grey defies categorisation - in other words, it‘s a typical Jasper Fforde book.
There’s humour, political scheming, parallels with real life and 21st century issues such as class and race, wrapped up as science fiction - or is it?
Eddie Russett lives in a world of strict rules and regulations, where life is determined by the colour you can see. Excitement and danger are certainly not encouraged. But Eddie is of a curious and questioning disposition and not inclined to accept the status quo. Unfortunately for him, the Munsell Book of Wisdom clearly states that “Imaginative thought is to be discouraged. No good ever comes of it.”
Will Eddie move up the scale by marrying an Oxblood? Can he resist the lure of a cute and retroussé nose? Confused? You will be!
Verdict:“This book is like marmite - you’ll love it or hate it! Depending on your point of view, it’s either weird and wonderful or incomprehensible. If you haven’t read any of Fforde’s previous work, it may take you a few chapters to get into this book and several more chapters to work out what’s happening, but persevere and you’ll come to enjoy (or give up on) the unpredictable plot and witty dialogue.” ****
A few words of caution…..don’t eat the scones!
About Face: Donna Leon
 Newly out in paperback, this is the latest in Leon’s series of crime novels set in Venice and featuring Commissario Brunetti - a decent and compassionate man battling official bureaucracy and long held rivalries between regional police forces.
The story has at its heart an older man and his younger wife, an investigation into the illegal disposal of chemical waste and an unsolved murder, but it is as much about middle class life in Venice and Brunetti himself as it is about the investigation of crime.
Leon’s obvious love of Venice does not blind her or her characters to the corruption which is alleged to exist in Italy, but that and other darker elements in the book - lack of trust, even between old friends, the canals at night, and gloomy weather are balanced by joyful descriptions of food and references to Brunetti family life and their wider literary and political interests.
Verdict:“Not the best in the series. A less convincing plot than usual with an ending which left me feeling there were still some loose ends to be tied up. That said, the descriptions of streets and buildings, the weather and all those little trips to bars and coffee shops are so powerfully evocative, it deserves 3 stars for the few hours of escapism it provides. ***
Teatime for the Traditionally Built: Alexander McCall Smith
 The latest in the No1 Ladies’ Detective Agency series provides the usual mix of humour, delightful characters and low key plot. In this book, just released in paperback, there are all the familiar places and people. We discover what Mma Makutsi’s old rival is up to, what’s happening on and off the football pitch and the fate of Mma Ramotswe’s faithful white van.
With chapters called “Walking is good for you, and for Botswana” and “Tea with Mma Potokwani”, regular readers of Alexander McCall Smith’s detective series will know they are in for their usual reading treat. This is one of his best. No sex (unless you count the exploits of that “ruthless Jezebel”, Violet), no violence, no swearing, just good story-telling.
Verdict: A delight - as usual - a gentle, sympathetic portrait of life in and aroundBotswana’s No1 Ladies’ Detective Agency. If you’ve read any or all of the previous books in the series, you’ll love this one; if you haven’t, I urge you to give it a try. Wonderful*****
Directions For the Gardiner: And Other Horticultural Advice by John Evelyn, edited by Maggie Campbell-Culver
Something very different this month. A newly published hardback with source material written in the 17th century. The author – John Evelyn - is best known for his diary, which ranks along with Pepys in terms of observation.
Comprising three works, Directions for the Gardiner(sic), the Kalendarium Hortense, a guide to the gardening year, and Acetaria, on salad and herb crops, this is part gardening history and part “how to” guide, supplemented by advice on food preparation.
At first glance, it appears a serious, almost academic work, but delving more deeply it is clear that Evelyn's preserving hints and recipes could give Mrs Beeton a run for her money; his method for growing salad leaves in two hours is certainly worth considering, although I would advise against trying any year-old pickled asparagus.
Given the current interest in traditional, locally grown food, if this book catches on you should expect to see cowslips and “Herb pudding” in all the best restaurants in 2010. Meanwhile, it's time to plant hotbed melons, cucumbers and nectarines, transplant carnations and keep your bees inside their hives.
Verdict: An ideal gift for someone interested in both history and gardening. This book was not what I expected from the cover and, despite my limited interest in gardening, I am really enjoying it. It's one of those books which makes you want to read out snippets to whoever is near at hand.
My advice is to open it at random and read a page or two at a time - a book to savour when the weather is unsuitable for getting one's hands dirty and just the thing if you want to impress your friends with unusual home grown food, freshly prepared. ****
 Two murders, a country house, family secrets and a well known detective; it sounds like a classic whodunit. But, darker and more serious than the majority of murder mysteries, PD James’ writing is worlds away from the cosy domestic crime novels of Agatha Christie.
Few of the people in this book have any softening characteristics, most being deeply flawed. That could make for a pretty dispiriting read, however, a well thought out story, strong on atmosphere and which builds tension almost to the end ensures readers get exactly what those familiar with James’ detective stories have come to expect.
Verdict: A quality read for those who like their books strong on psychology and a bit more cerebral than the average.***
From February, my copy of the books I review will be available at the Harbour Club in Portscatho to be sold in aid of Air Ambulance.
Simon’s cat by Simon Tofield
 Simon's Cat is based on an amalgamation of the author’s three cats. His everyday adventures will be familiar to anyone with a passing knowledge of cat behaviour.
Fresh from a starring role in four YouTube cartoons, Simon’s cat is every bit as amusing and full of personality on the page. The book is full of witty and wonderful drawings, which manage to be both simple and detailed, always amusing, sharply observed and, very often, laugh out loud funny.
Although it’s tempting to sit down and read it all the way through, it’s worth rationing it to a few pages each evening, just to spread the treat over a longer period.
Verdict: If you are one of the 25 million who have seen the wonderful Simon’s cat on YouTube, you won’t need any encouragement to buy this book. If you haven’t checked out YouTube, but if you like cats, you’ll love the book anyway*****
 How to get things done without trying too hard, by Richard Templar- with Christmas preparations and family visits on the horizon, this sounded like a timely read.
Many of the suggestions aren’t new but, as the author says, even if you only take forward one or two of them you might free up a little time. Some techniques will work for one person but not another; many are more appropriate to people in employment, some are obvious, but you would have to be either very organised or a very determined time waster not to find something to help you get more done.
Amongst other things, Templar suggests making lists, grouping things e.g. in the order you plan to visit certain shops, checking your diary for a few weeks ahead so you can buy several birthday cards at once, standing up to take phone calls (you really do talk for less time). He also includes some tips to improve memory and some assertiveness techniques.
Verdict: An easy read- short chapters covering one or two techniques…you don‘t even have to try too hard to read the book. Putting it into practice may take a little longer, but give it a go. Even if you hate the book you can give it to a friend - that‘s one present sorted!****
 Seeds of Terror, by Gretchen Peters, 2009 - If current affairs is your thing then this in depth account of how heroin is bankrolling the Taliban may well be worth a look. The focus is our course the drugs trade in Afghanistan and its often underplayed role in the current conflict there. Over the last few years the poppy, Peters argues, saved the Taliban from virtual extinction and she makes a strong argument that the conflict is now more to do with heroin distribution than ideology. You also get something of a potted history of Afghanistan, which includes a fair share on the general idiocy of British and American foreign policy to the region; for example, our decision to fund and arm the Mujahadeen, to help them fight a Holy War against the Russians. Significantly arming Jihadi groups in complex, conflict-ridden tribal regions with poor or non existent governance? And for my next trick, here is a chocolate teapot!
Verdict: “Informative, entertaining and very readable. Peters makes what sounds like the subject of a research paper, read like a political thriller”.
 The Book Lovers’ Appreciation Society, a collection of short stories by various authors, including Anne Fine, Sophie Kinsella and Joanna Trollope
If you like so-called chick-lit and are looking for something to read which is not too taxing - a book ready split into bite sized chunks - then you’ll probably like this collection of short stories.
This book was described as containing “irresistible tales of love, friendship, passion and betrayal“. But, despite the wide range of writers, I have to confess - and this may be the result of reading this book in one sitting - I found many of the stories very similar, with one or two exceptions e.g. the Alexander McCall Smith story featuring the wonderful Mma Ramotswe.
Verdict:Familiar comfort reading - great if that’s what you’re looking for. I readily admit this is not my kind of book, so two stars (including one for the donation to charity)** £1 from every book sold goes to the Breast Cancer Care charity
 Divine Justice, by David Balducci
Reading this book it was easy to picture a film version with Bruce Willis as Oliver Stone, war hero, former CIA operative, one of America’s “Most Wanted” and all round good guy. Cue also Julia Roberts as the love interest.
Although there are all the usual suspects and ingredients, it is not completely predictable. A complex plot, lots of action, a couple of assassinations, a manhunt, uncertainty about who is on the “right” side and who can be trusted, corruption, past injustices and the need to fight the establishment (alone, naturally), all made for a good read. I hope it makes it onto film - it could be another Die Hard (if they cast Alan Rickman as one of the villains!)
Verdict: If you’ve read Balducci’s previous books, you’ll love this one; if you haven’t, but you enjoy well paced thrillers, you’ll probably like it. ***
 The Guernsey Literary And Potato Peel Pie Society, Mary Ann Shaffer and Annie Barrows (2009) - I am a book addict. I would be quite happy to sit in a room with fellow addicts, tell them my name and admit to my problem. Every now and then I force myself to cull the shelves in my house and give away the books I read once and really won’t ever read again. Really won’t read again. Ever.
It is, therefore, a truly wonderful thing to find a new book that I know will become a much-loved treasure, a book that I will read and savour again and again. The book that I have discovered is titled “The Guernsey Literary And Potato Peel Pie Society”.
I started it unsure of what I was letting myself in for as it seemed to consist of nothing but letters, letters from an author named Juliet to various characters and from them to her.
I found that I very quickly became comfortable with the concept, as the writing is quite simply marvelous.
The book has two authors, Mary Ann Shaffer and Annie Barrows. Mary Ann Shaffer became ill as she was writing and her niece, Annie Barrows, stepped in to help finish the novel as her aunt’s health declined. It is a tragedy that May Ann did not live to see her book become such a success. It is written with wit and charm as well as a sly humour that not only echoes the period, England in 1946, but also carries through to make the reader of today laugh out loud.
Some of the story is so funny I found myself snorting with laughter whilst other parts moved me to tears. It is a harrowing story full of hardship but also full of individual acts of heroism. It resonates with tenderness and the compassion that people are capable of along with the depths of cruelty to which they will, at times, sink.
The heroine of the book, Juliet Ashton, comes to know of the existence of the Literary Society through a letter she receives from a farmer on the island of Guernsey. As their correspondence progresses, she is drawn into the tale of what happened to the islanders during the German occupation during the Second World War and their continued battle to adjust to life in the aftermath of the conflict. We also learn of Juliet’s own experiences during the war and her search to find her place in the world.
The book is a tribute to the people of Guernsey, a tale of a doomed love and a joy filled romantic comedy.
It is tempting to share the whole story, giving away the twists and turns in the plot, however I am firmly of the opinion that this would be to really spoil the joy of discovering the book for yourself.
Verdict: If you are going to treat yourself to one book this autumn, make it this one - I promise that you will not be disappointed ***** Isabel Cave
 A Man Derailed, Paul Holmes, Chipmunk Publishing (available in paperback and as an e-book. Strong language) - first, I must declare an interest - Paul is a friend of mine and spent some time in St Mawes during his recovery period; like many of us, he discovered the healing properties of the Roseland … perhaps that’s for another book?
This is not a book written by a professional author, it is the story of an ordinary man, going about his day to day life when, as a result of just one incident, everything changed.
Paul was involved in terrible work-related accident - not his fault - which led to depression, anger and ongoing feelings of powerlessness. He tells of the effects on his job, his health, his sanity and his life.
It is not a comfortable read, but if you have ever suffered from depression, or you have been close to someone who has, you will recognise so much of what is described. The book has the best description of isolation and anger I have ever read, made all the more striking because the real Paul is a gentle, good humoured and thoughtful person. You may think this book has little to do with Cornwall. But read it and you will probably never think of FistralBeach in quite the same way.
Verdict: “While no-one could say this is a book to enjoy, it does give a very clear picture of what depression can feel like and it reinforces the need for support and friendship. Know someone feeling low? Give them a call them now".**** Sallie Eden.
 The Damned United, David Peace (2006), Faber and Faber - If you’ve seen the film, why not read the book as well. This fascinating account of Brian Clough’s struggle in management from lowly Derby County to the infamous Leeds United of the 1970’s, has been described as the best sporting book ever! That it may well be, but it also holds its own as a brilliant piece of fiction writing and a compelling insight into the mind of a man in crisis. Whatever ‘it’ is when it comes to writing, David Peace has in abundance!
Verdict: “A real gem of a book, football fan or not" *****
 Rough Music, by Patrick Gale (2000) - Patrick Gale, who lives near Land’s End, has been invited to appear at this year’s Roseland Festival, so although this book was first published in 2000, it is a good time to read it (or re-read it). Partly drawing on his own life, and largely set in Cornwall, the author has written a haunting tale of childhood innocence. His writing seems effortless, though doubtless it isn’t, and reading it is sheer pleasure, despite some painful family disclosures and the terrible effects of events which took place years before. The juxtaposition of Julian’s cheerful view of his world and the anger and regret of the adults who surround him skilfully mixes the simplicity of childhood with complex adult situations.
The author draws together the different layers of the story - sexual awareness, the increasing confusion of Julian’s mother and his sister’s resentment - with such subtlety that each strand blends into the next leaving the reader hardly aware of the change of time or place.
Verdict“This was a beautifully written story and I can’t wait to read the rest of his books.”**** (Sallie Eden)
 The Great Western Beach: A Memoir of a Cornish Childhood Between The Wars, by Emma Smith, 2009 - the story of a middle class 1920's childhood in north Cornwall; a time and place in which summers were long and perpetually sunny and bad weather was an infrequent, but exciting, interruption in a life of beach picnics, tea parties, car trips and occasional education.
But this otherwise happy period suffered from a different type of storm - instigated by the author's father, an angry and disappointed war hero. In describing his moods and their impact, the author makes us see clearly the difficulties in the life of this middle class family, striving to present a positive front on a limited income.
Happily the black periods are relieved by descriptions of sea bathing, rockpooling, and occasional visits to generous, often eccentric, relatives and friends.
Above all we are reminded that some things really haven't changed - parking problems, packed beaches and the simple pleasure of being near the sea.
Verdict: "After a slow start the story creates a vivid picture of beach adventures, family picnics and the delights of a simpler age. A reminder of what is so special about childhood and Cornwall. Add it to your Christmas list and enjoy some sunshine over the winter ” **** (Sallie Eden).
 August Heat by Andrea Camilleri, published in hardback by Picador, 2009 -in AugustHeat, our hero Inspector Salvo Montalbano is in a far more ponderous mood than he has been in the previous novels in Andrea Camilleris’ wonderfully atmospheric Sicilian detective series. This tenth outing for his detective creation finds Montalbanos’ colleague Mimi Augello delayed in returning from holiday – meaning Montalbano and his long-suffering girlfriend Livia have to spend their own summer break at home in the searing heat, forcing them to rent a villa by the sea. However they soon suspect the place is cursed following plagues of cockroaches, mice, and spiders, - and the discovery of the body of young girl hidden away in a trunk! And so another entertaining Montalbano investigation is launched with the ensuing trail of vice and deception.
Verdict: “delicious meals, long swims, and a good detective story. All the trademark warmth and humour of Camilleris’ ever-gripping detective series” ****
Did you know -Andrea Camilleri is the most successful author in Italy; yet little more than a decade ago he was a virtually unknown seventy year old who had written a handful of historical novels (Kate Acres).
 Before the Mast: In the Grain Races of the 1930s, Written by Geoffrey Sykes Robertshaw, Edited by Elvin Carter -excitement, hard work, tedium and a love of the sea in equal measure - the day-to-day life of an Able Seaman who served on some of the famous Tall Ships during the 30s. Elvin Carter has drawn on original handwritten logs to produce a fascinating book, illustrated by photographs taken during the four month voyages between Australia and Falmouth. The photographs of the crew, rough weather, and life onboard were taken on a Kodak Number Two Box Brownie, and, although they are around 75 years old, the clarity is amazing. Descriptions of everything from petty niggles to weather conditions, from fellow crew to wildlife and the joy of clean clothes, mean this book has something for everyone.
Verdict: “The story is fascinating and Elvin’s enthusiasm for his subject shines through. The result makes it almost like being there…but grateful that you aren‘t!” ****(Sallie)
 The Potato, Larry Zuckerman, first published 1999 - it’s ten-years since Larry Zuckerman first brought us the story of how a vegetable changed history in this well-researched, informative, and very entertaining book on the common spud. Actually according to the author it turns out that the spud isn’t so common after all – to C16 Peruvians it was a delicacy, in Spain it was a rich man’s food, and Henry VIII thought them the height of chic and even believed potatoes to be an aphrodisiac. Interesting facts aside, Zuckerman’s unique approach to history in this book – to look at famine, population explosions, social development, and women’s rights through the ‘eye’ of a tuber (if you pardon the pun) – makes ‘The Potato’ definitely worthy of our attention, and a jolly good read to boot.
Verdict:“A little gold nugget of a book; something to dip in and out of, like a tasty bag of potato chips” **** (MB)
 The Genesis Secret – Tom Knox, Published 2009 -In the sandblown deserts of Turkey, beautiful Archaeologist Christine Meyer is unknowingly on one of mankind’s most historic digs. After a traumatic time in Israel, reporting on an innocent child’s death, ace reporter Rob Luttrell is sent by his editor on a supposedly easy story; to report on the Turkish excavation. But as murders starttaking place all over the globe, it isn’t long before both Rob and Christine are in a race for life against a psychotic millionaire; to save themselves, their loved ones and the social structure of the modern world.(MH)
Verdict: "Intense and gripping adventure thriller" ***
 Archangel,by Rober Harris, first published 1998 - Set in post-communist Russia, Archangel was Harris’s third novel in the ‘historical fiction’ genre (following Enigma and Fatherland) and a gripping yarn at that. Our main protagonist is the bedraggled historian, Christopher ‘Fluke’ Kelso, who whilst attending the world’s dullest history conference in Moscow runs into Papu Rapava – an secretive old Russian fixer who claims he was present at Stalin’s deathbed and what’s more, that Stalin kept a secret notebook! Any excuse to escape the conference, Fluke embarks on a shadowy quest to hunt down the leather clad diary, taking in much of modern Russia’s grim undertow in the process, and ending up in the freezing and remote Russian seaport of Archangel. But can Fluke handle the notebooks biggest secret of all? (MB)
Verdict: “Atmospheric historical thriller with a good twist” ****
 The Book of Gerrans and Portscatho: From Churchtown to Lugger End, by Chris Pollard, First Published 2008 - If you’re a fan of local history, this may very-well be for you. Pollard recalls the life and times of the Roseland villages of Gerrans and Portscatho through well-told tales of old inns, old wrecks, coastguards, and visiting naturalists. Of particular note is the story of The Gustav – the German barque which stranded off nearby Porthcurnick beach in 1912, and the wreck of the Carl Hirschenberg in 1891. If you like this book – which also includes some really impressive old photography - be sure to look out for The book of St Mawes by the same author. (MB)
Verdict: "A well-researched local interest title, which gives a snapshot of the Roseland of yesteryear" ****
DVD's Reviews
 'Avatar' starring Sam Worthington, Sigourney Weaver & Michelle Rodriguez, directed by James Cameron - Just when you think five-star filmmaking is a rare creature, two come along in one month! Proves the point, I guess. But it is with no exaggeration that I award this film accordingly. It's not so much the story - a sci-fi, other-world, boy-meets-girl - as the execution and drama. The action scenes are superbly shot and hold you on the edge of your seat for the full 2 1/2 hours, hardly noticing the soreness of your derrière, and the CGI (computer Graphic Imagery) is astoundingly good. It's been twelve years since his epic, 'Titanic' but director James Cameron, as then, hasn't let up on his attention to detail. The story is set in the future where we (humans) have travelled to a distant world to mine it. Naturally, the peaceful natives are unhappy about the invasion of their otherwise organically synchronized lifestyle, so we have to bring in the big guns to shake them up. In a last ditch attempt to see them off, the respectful scientists - headed by Weaver's character - let their minds be synchronized with 'avatars' of the species, but needless to say, they are unsuccessful, allowing the red-necks to have their dastardly way with the natives. As standard fare as this may seem, don't be put off by this synopsis; this is an excellently executed film. I even endured wearing the 3D glasses to sit with my Godchildren to watch it, and I can only say it enhanced the experience. Another must-see Cameron hit that will undoubtedly have financiers falling over themselves to fund his next epic.
Verdict: Everything you need in a modern epic... superb! *****
See trailer here.
 An Education: Directed by Lone Scherfig and starring Peter Sarsgaard, Carey Mulligan & Alfred Molina and adapted by novellist Nick Hornby from Lynn Barber's autobiography, is a Coming-of-age drama set in 1960s London. Jenny (Carey Mulligan) is an intelligent young woman on the brink of her 17th birthday, destined for a promising yet somewhat narrow future at Oxford University and beyond. Longing for romance and sophistication to inject some excitement into her humdrum schoolgirl existence, she finds herself caught in a whirlwind romance with the mysterious and much older playboy David (Peter Sarsgaard). It's not often an old synic like me egts to rave about a movie, but this one's a humdinger! Nick Hornby's first foray into scriptwriting is astonishingly good; the dialogue tight and beautifully written. That alone would be superb, but fused with the effortless portrayals by all the cast, not least the now BAFTA award winning and Oscar nominated Carey Mulligan (for this role). I could drivel on, but suffice to say; SEE THIS FILM!
Verdict:If you're gonna see one film this year... and all that! *****
See trailer here.
 Fantastic Mr. Fox: Directed by Wes Anderson and starring the voices of Owen Wilson, George Clooney, Meryl Streep, Willem Dafoe & Bill Murray, et al. From visionary director Wes Anderson this first animated film, utilizing classic handmade stop motion techniques, tells the story of the best selling children's book by Roald Dahl (author of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory and James and the Giant Peach). Three horrible farmers - Boggis, Bunce and Bean - are dedicated to destroying Mr. Fox, the wily and wonderful Mr Fox, who makes a habit of eating their chickens. When they pull out all the stops and surround his den, Mr Fox must use all his cunning in a fantastic plan to keep his family and countryside friends safe. This is most certainly made more for adults than children. The dialogue is tight and well honed, and the matching of characters to their voices, inspired, but I couldn't help feeling lost by the story. Somehow it all got a little too unbelievable. I didn't read the original book, and maybe it's just like the story We Anderson has adapted, but I just got to a point where I felt, "So what?" That said, it has more individuality than your standard Disney fare, so you can't have it all, I guess!
Verdict: A fun 1 1/2 hours, but not as engrossing as other Dahl adaptations. ***
See trailer here.
 The Hurt Locker: Directed by Kathryn Bigelow and starring Jeremy Renner, Anthony Mackie, Brian Geraghty. This is an intense and unflinching portrayal of elite soldiers who have one of the most dangerous jobs in the world: disarming bombs in the heat of combat. When a new sergeant, James, takes over a highly trained bomb disposal team amidst violent conflict, he surprises his two subordinates, Sanborn and Eldridge, by recklessly plunging them into a deadly game of urban combat. James behaves as if he's indifferent to death. As the men struggle to control their wild new leader, the city explodes into chaos, and James' true character reveals itself in a way that will change each man forever. This film took a heap of awards all over the globe (72, to be exact and 46 nominations) including six Ocars and a first Oscar ever for a female director. No mean achievement and well deserved, in my view. What is great about this movie is it doesn't try to be overly violent, nor sentimental. To walk such a fine line without being dull is a sound achievement in indeed. I was gripped from the first scene to the last and never once did I think "Schmalzt" or "Bloodthirsty", nevertheless it remained a powerful film and underplaying the music and the exstensive use of handheld cameras made the reality even more intense.
Verdict: A solid film with great performances that deserves all the praise it gets. ****
See trailer here.
 The Soloist; Directed by Joe Wright and starring Jamie Foxx and Robert Downey Jr. This emotionally soaring drama – and true story – is about the redemptive power of music. Journalist Steve Lopez (Robert Downey Jr. – don’t you just love this guy!?) discovers Nathaniel Anthony Ayers (Jamie Foxx), a former classical music prodigy, playing his violin on the streets of L.A. As Lopez endeavours to help the homeless man find his way back, a unique friendship is formed, one that transforms both their lives.
I'm a big fan of Downey Jr., and this is another great movie by the acclaimed actor. He adds so much humour to his roles, whether serious roles, like this, or playful, like ones 'Ironman'. Jamie Foxx, too, is a superb actor, so it is of little suprise that this was going to be a winner... and it was. It's a simple story of 'buddy love' but well portrayed and well directed... enough said!
Verdict: A lovely film that entertains and has a feel-good factor... break out the popcorn and the tissues! ***1/2
See trailer here.
 Surrogates: Directed by Jonathan Mostow and starring Bruce Willis. FBI agent (Bruce Willis) investigates the murder of a student linked to the man who helped create a high-tech surrogate phenomenon that allows people to purchase unflawed robotic versions of themselves, enabling people to experience everything from the comfort of their own homes.
Well, it sounds confusing, but isn't. However, it isn't a top notch Willis movie, either. Somehow the film never really gets started and the idea that everyone is a clone, doesn't help the forward movement. If you're a die hard Willis fan (did you see what I did there?), then it's worth checking out, but I wasn't blown away. That said, it's not the worst 90 minutes I've spent in front of the box this year, either.
Verdict: Missable, but entertaining. **
 Time Traveler's Wife: Directed by Robert Schwentke and starring Eric Bana and Rachel McAdams. The Time Traveler's Wife is based on the best-selling book about a love that transcends time. Clare has been in love with Henry her entire life. She believes they are destined to be together, even though she never knows when they will be separated. Henry is a time traveler - cursed with a rare genetic anomaly that causes him to live his life on a shifting timeline, skipping back and forth through his lifespan with no control. Despite the fact that Henry's travels force them apart with no warning, Clare desperately tries to build a life with her one true love.
As bizarre as this premise sounds, this film, as the book, is absorbing and well made. Films made from bestselling novels always carry the burden of comparison (it's terribly hard to compress 500 pages into just 90 without losing somthing of the former - believe me, I know!) but veteran screenplay writer Bruce Joel Rubin (Ghost, Jacob's Ladder) has done a great job. Admittidley it's been a couple of years since I read Audrey Niffenegger's novel, but it seems to have been a success and, judging by the full house at Portscatho Harbour Club's screening, a popular choice.
Verdict: A solid movie that successfully transcends a slushy mire to deliver an enjoyable film. ***1/2
 The Invention Of Lying: Written and directed by Ricky Gervais and Matthew Robinson, this hilarious comedy takes place in an alternative reality in which lying does not exist. Everyone, even politicians and advertisers, speaks the truth (and nothing but the truth). But when a loser named Mark (Gervais) discovers lying, he finds that dishonesty has its rewards. In a world where every word is assumed to be the absolute truth, Mark succeeds in lying his way to fame and fortune. But things soon get out of control, as people start to treat his lies as gospel; he has the entire world hanging on his every word - but can he win the heart of the woman he loves?
It's not very flattering to compare an actor to a condiment, but Ricky Gervais, like Marmite, is someone you either love or hate. Personally, I think he's a British comedic icon - which is why I loved this film on many levels, albeit not as good as 'Ghost Town' - but, as I discovered in the pub on Friday night, he also
inspires venomous distaste in the minds of others. Why that it, I can only imagine (and certainly don't want to get into here - although I'd love to hear your views for the letter's page) but 'The Invention Of Lying' - if you are a fan - is typical Gervaison fare, and one which I, at least, would recommend to everyone.
Verdict: Not his best, but certainly very amusing, with an interesting topic for discussion... namely; are white-lies really all that bad? ***
 The Taking Of Pelham 123: In Tony Scott's re-make of the 1978 classic thriller, Walter Garber (Denzel Washington) is a New York City subway dispatcher whose ordinary day is thrown into chaos by an audacious crime: the hijacking of a subway train. Ryder (John Travolta), the criminal mastermind behind the hijacking and leader of a highly-armed gang of four, threatens to execute the train's passengers unless a large ransom is paid within one hour. As the tension mounts beneath his feet, Garber employs his vast knowledge of the subway system in a battle to outwit Ryder and save the hostages. But there's one riddle Garber can't solve: even if the thieves get the money, how can they possibly escape? This is a great 90 minute escape and full of action that unfortunately lets itself down with the 'coperate' ending. Sometimes a film feels like a bunch of studio execs have sat around, discussing how a film should leave us with the all important 'feel-good' factor, and this is one of them. I understand why the do it, but despair when it's been so obviously sliced around with a machete by editors and corporates. Nevertheless, an enjoyable romp with some nice imperfect heroes.
Verdict: A high-energy romp on the circle line, but some unexpected cancellatons due to corporate interference. ***
 ‘This Is It - Michael Jackson’ is a rare, behind-the-scenes look at the performer as he developed, created and rehearsed for his sold-out concerts at London's O2 Arena. And an exceptional insight it is, too. The extraordinary way his producer, entourage, musicians and dancers not only – but understandably – idolise the man, but walk around on eggshells whenever he is present, is a sight to behold. However, his clarity of vision and dance and musical prowess, belies the innocence and complexity of this man’s legendary character. If you’re anything like me, you’ll be absorbed from the first moment to the last at the artistry, brilliance, childlike phenomenon that was Jacko. One thing’s for sure, his schizophrenic persona.
Verdict: A must-see film which portrays the complexity of character of the ‘King of Pop’. ****
 The Age Of Stupid - Oscar nominated Pete Postlethwaite stars as a man living alone in 2055, looking back at old footage of 2008 and asking, “why didn't we stop climate change when we had the chance?”. This engaging film cleverly intertwines between several documentaries whilst Postlethwaite narrates over the footage, skipping backwards and forwards, slowly revealing the horrific results of climate change. I left feeling challenged, angry and empowered to make a difference and I cannot recommend this film highly enough to anyone wanting to see the possible outcome of our environmental apathy and indecision.
Verdict: An important film that will shake the foundations of our combined consciousnesses. *****
This film will be shown at the Harbour Club, Portscatho on Monday 18th January.
 Home – This stunning documentary by world renowned areal photographer Yann Arthus Bertrand is a mesmerising piece of work. Combining exceptionally stunning moving images of the earth from above - a trademark that has seen street exhibitions of his photography please the public and critics alike throughout the world – with the mesmerising voice of actress Glenn Close, we are taken on a journey from the birth of planet earth, to the rise of humanity and the latter’s effects on the ‘home’ we all inhabit. Unlike ‘The Age Of Stupid’, however we are left with a mix of awe and hopefulness as we leave the cinema. I think both have their place in the environmental movement, but where ‘Stupid’ whips us into action, ‘home’ will appeal to those who to be led down the environmental path with a rod of candy... but the route, nevertheless, will lead those who take it to Rome.
Verdict: A soft and ‘eye-candy’ induced trip down the environmental ladder. ****
This film will be shown at the Harbour Club, Portscatho on Monday 11th January.
 Sunshine Cleaning, starring Amy Adams, Emily Blunt and Alan Arkin. Wonderful, wonderful, wonderful! This light dramedy (Comedy Drama) sees two down-on-their-luck sisters drift into the murky world of ‘crime scene cleanups’. Blunt (Young Victoria, Devil Wears Prada) plays a rebellious sibling who can’t hold down a job. Her sister (Adams - Enchanted) desperately wants to be accepted by her old school friends whilst trying to earn enough to re-school her troubled son. But just as the sisters’ long-lost mutual closeness reawakens, the troubles of the world pound even harder, leading them from disaster to disaster. This is a chick-flick with a masculine kick... one where you can’t help but feel empathy for their unrelenting fight against the odds, but one that will guarantee you a positive feel-good glow by the end of the movie.
Verdict: Another superb hit from the makers of ‘Little Miss Sunshine’. ****
This film will be shown at the Harbour Club, Portscatho on Monday 4th January.
 The Proposal, starring Sandra Bullock and Ryan Reynolds, Directed by Anne Fletcher –Hurrah! Sandra Bullock is back with a vengeance. In this charming comedy – her first since the popular Miss Congeniality – Ms Bullock plays a high powered publishing editor who finds out she’s about to be deported. Just as she things her number’s up, her long suffering assistant (Reynolds) puts his head around the door. Before he can say ‘I don’t!’ she makes him an offer he can’t refuse; marry me so I can stay in the country, or lose your job. What follows is a very funny, although predictable, 90 minute romp back to his family home where they escape to avoid the sceptical immigration official, only to find themselves even deeper in the drink.This comedy puts Bullock back to where she should be: in the ‘A’ list Hollywood RomCom genre, and sustains RyanReynolds line of hits including the hilarious Just Friends and Definately Maybe.
Verdict: A hilariousand charming HollywoodRomComfrom two of its best purveyors!****
Moon, starring Sam Rockwell and the voice of Kevin Spacey, Directed by Duncan Jones –Astronaut Sam Bell (Rockwell) has a quintessentially personal encounter toward the end of his three-year stint on the Moon, where he, working alongside his computer, GERTY (Spacey), sends back to Earth parcels of a resource that has helped diminish our planet's power problems. After leaving to repair a minor problem, Sam has an accident which ends up putting him into sickbay. He wakes up to find his replacement on the Moon, already there... it’s himself! WhenI read the synopsis of this film, I was wondering how on earth (if you’ll excuse the pun), could they maintain my interest in a film ostensibly starring one actor in one location... but it was amazing! Not only did they do that, and better than most films have over the last few years, but also had me on the edge of my seat for the whole time. This intriguing tale, written and directed by Duncan Jones (who changed the name his father gave him – Zowie Bowie – in the 90’s to avoid association with the superstar, and make it in his own right) is as entertaining as it is brilliantly thought out, and although you might think you know what’s going on before the end; I challenge you to work out what’s going to happen to him/them before theend.
Verdict: Topnotch Sci-Fi adventure which transcends its genre and makes it into the major league, truly earning its News Of The World review “One of the best films of the year”*****
 The September Issue, Directed by R.J. Cutler – Ifyou’ve ever wanted to know how the real life world of the most powerful woman in fashion works, then this fly-on-the-wall documentary is a must-see! For the first time since its publication’s history, Chief Editor of American Vogue, Anna Wintour allowed Cutler into the doors to film this astonishing documentary about the making of the September Issue – Vogue’s biggest issue of the year, and this, the biggest in the publication’s history. Watch as seasoned designer’s quake in their boots as Ms Wintour, with one twist of her nose, trashes their entire collections; watch how the press, high powered business men and advertising execs grovel for her acceptance at well-heeled dinner parties. This truly must have been gold dust for the cast of ‘The Devil Wears Prada’ and one could be mistaken for thinking that they overdid their portrayal of their real life counter-parts. In reality, though, it’s the real life counterparts who out-diva the actors. If it wasn’t a documentary, I could well believe it to be a parody. They do say that fact is stranger than fiction, and this film proves it!
Verdict: An entertaining and insightful documentary which gives a no-comment insight into the heady world of the fashionindustry” ****
 Synecdoche, New York, starring Phillip Seymour Hoffman and Catherine Keener, Directed by Charlie Kaufman – Pitched as “The hugely anticipated film which stunned the world and smashed the Box Office...” this film by legendary scriptwriter Charlie Kaufmann sees a theatre director’s seemingly insane mission to create a stage play of his own life. Receiving a 'genius grant' for his work, he sees a way of addressing the despair he feels, and moves his theatre company to a warehouse in New York City to embark on the lifelong project.Starring some of America’s finest actors – hardly surprising given that Charlie Kaufman’s films (‘Being John Malkovich’, and the spectacular ‘Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind’ are world acclaimed – I was expecting something special. And on the acting front, I wasn’t disappointed. But the film’s content only reminded me of my agent’s wise words to any potential scriptwriter/director: “If you are a screenplay writer first, wouldn’t you want a better director than yourself to direct your films?” And in the instance of Synecdoche, I think the answer should have been a resounding, YES! Charlie Kaufman made what could have been a tremendous idea into a self-absorbed, long-winded film which, I’m sure, screenplay writers workshops will be discussing for decades. But the average Joe in the street (of which I consider myself one) it’ll just go right over their heads. Restraint can be an asset when working with great talent, but none of that, neither by the producers or the studio execs, given Kaufman’s past record, observed. Sad, ‘cos I, for one, was really looking forward to seeing this genius’s directorial debut. Oh, well, you can’t have a winner every time, I guess.
Verdict: A film acted with style but lacking any real commercial content... for the hardcore movie goer only! **
Change ling (2008), Directed by Clint Eastwood, starring Angelina Jolie and John Malkovich - grim offering from Clint Eastwood, based on the true story of an everyday mum who goes head to head with the LAPD following the disappearance of her son. What makes the situation worse is that the corrupt and beleaguered police force, return to the stricken mother the wrong boy and then refuse to admit to their error.
Well put together by Eastwood and competent performances from Jolie and Malkovich means it’s worth a look. But Jolly, Jolie isn’t – which is to be expected given the subject matter.
Verdict: Not exactly feel good. Makes Million Dollar Baby look like the Life of Brian **
 State of Play, starring Russell Crowe, Ben Afflick and Helen Mirren - Thriller lovers, hang on to your hats. I have been waiting for this film for months and, once arrived, I wasn't dissapointed. Russell Crowe plays a Washington Post reported whose friend, Ben Afflick, a handsome and charasmatic Congressman is embued in a political scandal when his lover is suddenly reported dead. Turning to his reporter friend for help, he tries to proove his innocence, but as the plot unfolds, it slowly becomes evident that all is not what it seems.
This fast paced, plotical thriller will keep you glued to your seat for its entire 122 minutes. Blink and you'll miss the plot, so make sure you switch off the phone before pressing play!
Verdict: A well acted, fast paced thriller from director, Kevin Macdonald (The last King of Scotland) ****
The Boat That Rocked (2009), Directed by Richard Curtis and starring Philip Seymour Hoffman, Bill Nighy & Emma Thompson - Richard Curtis delves into the world of 60's pirate radio in this coming-of-age comedy. Amidst a cast of crazies, played by the likes of Philip Seymour Hoffman and Bill Nighy, disillusioned teen Carl is about to experience the rebellious spirit of rock 'n' roll, Radio Rock-style!
Well, great logline, but did the film actually live up to its hype? Before I give my views, I want to try and qualify the hype... and it’s not unsubstantial. The director and writer, Richard Curtis, is responsible for massive BritComs like "Love, Actually”, “Four Weddings...”, “Notting Hill” and “Bridgette Jones”, to name but a few.
Then you have the great Bill Nighy (“Love Actually”, Pirates of the Caribbean”), Phillip Seymour Hoffman, (“Along Came Polly”, “Magnolia”, Doubt” – reviewed below) and Emma Thompson, (“Sense and Sensibility”, “Love Actually”), and without even going into the likes of Kenneth Branagh’s, Rhys Ifans’, Chris O'Dowd’s and Rhys Darby’s pedigree, I think you get the picture... this film is drowning in talent! So why did it do just that...? I don’t know.
Casting the wrong lead in Tom Sturridge was a start for me. Surrounded by that cast, anyone would look bland, but Tom did little to fight his way through in my opinion. The jokes were over rehearsed and over staged and the believability of the story became thinner and thinner as the film rolled on. So, by the end – barring a few really nice moments, I must admit – I was glad to see the credits in sight (which I did, half hour before it was well overdue).
I am big fans off all of these actors and, as a screenwriter myself, am in total awe of Richard Curtis’ entire body of work. All, that is, bar this one. Pity, as I was waiting months to see this little gem and it turned out to be a rock (if you’ll excuse the pun!)
Verdict: "Disappointing, potentially brilliant yarn which did little to further the reputations of the God’s involved". **
 Yella (2008), Directed by Christian Petzold and starring Nina Hoss & Devid Striesow – this Silver bear winning film follows the escapades of a recently divorced woman. After a car crash, Yella beaks free of her husband’s ties and flees to Hannover to start a new job. On her arrival, however, she discovers the company has gone bust. An accidental meeting with a businessman in the hotel she is staying at, starts her on a path of discovery; a talent for high-finance. That is, until the reappearance of her ex husband who drives her to at last face her past.
This thriller holds an unexpected ending as well as punches of what at first seem to be strange events; but all will reveal itself at the end. Although absorbed, I found the film to be somewhat odd, but an interesting German film, nevertheless, and one I would recommend to all thriller enthusiasts.
Verdict: "Absorbing, but lacking the WOW factor that keeps you to your seat". ***
 Being Julia (2004)Directed by Istvan Szabo and starring Annette Bening, Jeremy Irons & Michael Gambon
– based on W. Somserset Maugham's novel, this star studded film is a delicious tale of amorous folly and revenge set in the world of the London stage during the late 1930s. Julia Lambert (Bening) is a celebrated and glamorous actress, famous throughout England and happily married for years to her agent, Michael (Irons). But underneath the artifice, she is being tortured by her fading looks, her philandering husband. Then she meets Tom, a young American admirer, and is swept off her feet; embarking on a secret and passionate affair that threatens to create a social scandal and destroy her career and marriage. Soon, however, she discovers that he has had an ulterior motive all along. There is no way that Julia Lambert is going to be taken for a fool, and she plans her revenge, the ultimate act of a woman scorned.
A delight! Rarely do you see actors of this quality in a farce, but the combination is wonderful. Not only does Ronald Harwood’s script flow beautifully, but it is enhanced by the portrayal’s, courtesy of some of the UK (and US’s) best modern performers.
Verdict: "Press play and sit back to 1 ½ hours of pure delight!" *****
O'Horten (2009) Directed by Bent Hamer and starring Bård Owe - This ullery charming film sees Odd Horten, a 67-year-old engineer who is due to retire after forty years of dutiful service. His world of punctuality, regime and order is set into disarray after being locked out of a friend's apartment on the eve of his retirement. Thrown into chaos, he has one strange encounter after another person who challenge the way he has been living and who direct him towards a deeper understanding of himself and his needs.
I haven't seen such a rewarding, insightful and understated film of this magnitude for many years, and one that only us Europeans could produce. Please see this movie...! Even if you do find subtitles hard work... I guarantee it's worth 86 minutes of anyone's time.
Verdict: Top notch Norwegian cinema; charming, sincere and beautifully crafted. ***** MDH Click here to see the trailer.
 Doubt (2009) Directed by John Patrick Shanley and starring Meryl Streep, Philip Seymour Hoffman, Amy Adams & Viola Davis -j
ust the names on the cast list should be enough to tell you this is going to be a film of epic acting proportions... and it doesn’t disappoint. This film, by 2nd time director John
Patrick Shanley (how on earth he gets a cast like this after Joe and the Volcano, I’ll never know) is brilliantly done. With the raw imagery, expectant of a catholic school run by nuns in 1964 Bronx, is suitably cold and the performances by the Oscar nominated cast (all four of them for this film!) are breathtaking. When the popular and progressive parish priest shows special interest in the first black child to be taken into the school, the head-teacher nun (Streep) starts a witch hunt to discover the reasons for this ‘unhealthy’ relationship.
Verdict: This did-he-or-didn’t-he story has twists and turns that keep you on the edge until the final scene... and then some. Brilliant enough for me to risk my reputation (what reputation!?) and give it the max points. ***** MDH
Click here to see the trailer.
 Duplicity (2009) Directed by Tony Gilroy and starring Clive Owen and Julian Roberts - directed by the writer/director of Michael Clayton, Duplicity follows Julia Roberts as a CIA operative and Clive Owen an MI6 player, who spy on competing corporate high level top secret business companies who may, or may not be conning each other. It opens in a typical ‘Steven Soderbergh’ fashion, with fast cut edits and cool music. The film continues using Sonderberg’s style timeline jumps between past and present, keeping the viewer on their toes (this is not a film to miss two minutes to get a beer... you’ll be lost!). Personally I like this kind of fast cut, high energy movie, and was looking forward to seeing it, despite very varies reviews, but the end left me less than satisfied. I won’t spoil it for you by revealing the end, but suffice to say Tony Gilroy’s writing didn’t hold the promise I was so eagerly expecting.
Verdict: Certainly one to see and enjoy, but lacking on final punch. *** MDH Click here to see trailer.
Bolt (2009) –Starring the voices of John Travolta and Miley Cirus - This cute story follows the escapades of a TV star dog. Unbeknown to him, the special powers he believes to have are only a figment of the production director’s imagination. One day, he mistakenly gets shipped to New York in a crate. Slowly, as he makes his way across America with his unlikely new found friends (a cat and a hamster) to be reunited with his ‘person’, he discovers the painful truth that he isn’t the invincible dog he believes himself to be, but just your average mutt.
The story is told with the usual Disney perfection. Adult’s as well as kid’s joke abound which will entertain the whole family, with the usual drama and story curves at all the right moments. In fact, I can’t help feeling that is the film’s downfall; everything seems almost too formatted – Toy Story with animals – haven’t we been this way before? That said, I’m probably being over critical of a film which will undoubtedly entertain the whole family who will take it on face value; another well crafted Disney escapade.
Verdict: "Fun for the whole family, although not in the same league as Pixar's 'The Incredibles'." *** (MDH) - Click Here to See Trailer
 The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (2009) Directed by David Fincher, with Brad Pitt, Cate Blanchett, Julia Ormond -this is about the course of true love, and sees a man, abandoned by his father for being excessively ugly - Benjamin Button (Brad Pitt) - age backwards. He starts an old man, born with severe arthritis, and slowly reverts to childhood. We follow his life and loves – played by the astonishing CateBlanchett – whom he meets as an eight year old (seventy year old). Over years of correspondence they find each other again, both now at middle age, and enjoy some devoted years before falling apart for the sake of their child. Seen through the eyes of that child (Julia Ormond), this is a beautiful and extraordinary tale, sensitively told by great direction (David Fincher – Panic, Fight Club) superb acting from the whole cast and astonishing special effects.
Verdict: “I can’t recommend this film highly enough if you’ve got two and a half hours to burn!” **** (MDH) Click Here to See Trailer
 Grand Torino (2009) Directed by Clint Eastwood, with Clint Eastwood, Christopher Carley, and Bee Vang -Clint Eastwood plays Walt Kowalski, a prickly, ill-tempered Korean-war veteran and widower from Michegan. All Kowalski wants is a quiet, ‘American’, life. But when a family of Hmong from South East Asia move in next door, he reluctantly finds himself drawn in to another world, alien but alluring. And when their youngest son Thao attempts to steal his pride and joy - his 1972 Grand Torino automobile – Kowalski unexpectedly bonds with the young man, connecting in a way he cannot do with his own kin. Prejudice, gang violence and neighbourhood change are some of the key themes in this movie. But there’s nothing dark about Grand Torino - it’s just simply a very honest and a well-put together, film.
Verdict:“Another well acted and thought-provoking drama from Clint” *** (MB) Click Here to See Trailer
 Valkyrie (2009) Directed by Bryan Singer, with Tom Cruise, Kenneth Branagh, Bill Nighy and Terence Stamp - historical thriller based on the true story of how in 1944 a select group of German officers attempted to assassinate Adolf Hitler and force Operation Valkyrie – the mechanism to take control of Nazi Germany in a national emergency. As we all know, it didn’t work – but it’s a good story all the same, and the Director, Bryan Singer, even manages to drum up a little suspense. There’s a good cast as well. Tom Cruise is engaging as the chief would-be assassin, Colonel Claus von Stauffenberg, and he is well-supported by fellow conspirators Kenneth Brannagh, as Major Von Treckow, and Bill Nighy, as the uncertain Friedrich Olbricht. It was never going to be an oscar contender, but all in all Valkyrie’s entertaining and worth a look.
Verdict: “A solid choice for a rainy Sunday afternoon” *** (MB)
 Seven Pounds (2008) Directed by Gabrielle Muccino, with Will Smith, Rosario Dawson, Woody Harrelson - In one of the oddest story lines of the year, Will Smith stars as Ben Thomas, a suicidal US tax investigator who decides to give away several of his body-parts to seven strangers to atone for causing a fatal car accident (couldn’t he have just joined Peace Corps?). All is going to plan until Mr Thomas meets Mrs right! What will Ben do now? Some find Seven Pounds the best thing since sliced bread. I found it a bit bizarre and depressing, and by half way I was hoping Mr. Thomas would hurry-up and get it all over with! On a more postive note though, Woody Harrelson plays his cameo role - a blind telesales operative - with his usual brilliance.
Verdict: “You might love it, but think twice if lonely, depressed, or ill - it's not exactly feel good" **
Theatre Reviews
 Murder in the Cathedral by T.S. Eliot, performed by Veryan Players Truro Cathedral
How often is it that you see a play and then, days later, find yourself still wrestling with the deepest forces running through the plot? Did King Henry really wish Archbishop Thomas dead? Did Thomas seek martyrdom? For an amateur production of a difficult play to sow such seeds of questioning is remarkable. But surely it is T.S. Eliot’s play, but, if not that, then the genuine paradox surrounding the historical event. Or could it just be, just possibly, that Veryan Players truly punched above their weight in the production of Murder in the Cathedral, performed in Truro Cathedral on 17, 18 and 19 Match 2010?
One visitor was heard saying how lucky the Players were to have a professional actor to take the lead role; not so, this was only his second part in amateur dramatics. So, what about the director? Now that is much more solid ground since Coral Pepper is hugely experienced and this and her raw talent shone through. We’re still not quite there since the result came from a very large number of separate parts.
Just in case this is beginning to read as a bit too much like syrup, a finger needs to be pointed at the paradoxical downside. The Cathedral, whilst so obviously the right setting for this particular play, was quite without mercy in the way lines delivered  away from the hearer were sucked away into its darkest corners. It would probably be true to say that many in the audience heard only half the lines spoken. What is odd, though, is that truly it didn’t matter. This is no insult to T.S. Eliot, probably the opposite, since his writing is so rich that meaning flows out at so many levels.
Coral Pepper achieved a great thing with this production, that a little village drama club could first have the ambition to put on such a production, but then to actually have the balls to go through with it. She had the skill, drive and intuition to get just the right performances from everyone at just the right time, where it counts, on stage.
The history of the production does add to the story. More than two years ago the people of Veryan heard that Father Doug Robbins, a long time member of the Players, was to be appointed parish priest. St Symphorian, as with all ancient church buildings, eats money and the suggestion emerged that the Players might devote one of their productions as a fund raising event. Murder in the Cathedral had the right religious pedigree and so the plan took flesh. A winter of rehearsals emerged into the first performances in St Symphorian, Veryan. So impressed was one member of the audience that the Cathedral suggested that they might host the next performances the following year, this time for their own fund raising, Inspire Cornwall. Another winter of rehearsals blossomed into the performances in the Cathedral.
The standard has been raised Veryan Players, what’s next?
Phil Williams
 Ladies Day, by Veryan Players - Local dramatics have always been something of a quandary for me; should I make my apologies and stay home for Big Brother for the risk being bored to tears by rather lacklustre performan-ces, or go, and try to look enthusiastic when asked how I enjoyed it?
So, it was with some trepidation that I went to the memorial hall in Portscatho to see the Veryan players' portrayal of Amanda Whitting-ton's 'Ladies Day' on Thursday night.
The play sees a group of four heavily-accented Hull women taking the day off work from their dreary jobs in a fish factory, slipping off their hairnets to don their Sunday best and head to the races. Once there, the foursome - now fish out of different water - make the most of this once in a lifetime opportunity to mix it with posh folk, a trip that, of course, ends in chaos.
With simple sets, giving the actors little to hide behind, the cast, including our own gardening guru, Nicola Bush (as the wannabe star, Shelly), her daughter Ellie (as the airhead, Linda), Louise Taylor (as the über proper, Jan) and Coral Pepper (as the retiree, Pearl) are pushed into giving their best - especially for this reviewer!
For the first few minutes, I was hiding behind my hands, awaiting the worst, but it wasn't long before by eyes started to pop out from behind my grubby little fingers, followed by the rest of my face.
By the half way point, I was charmed by the story and the main actor's portrayal of their roles and so, at the interval, it didn't cross my mind to make my usual dash for the pub and leave my seat empty for the second act.
As the second half took hold, now in-tune (and dare I be a luvvie and use the word "connected") with the characters, I was lifted through to the end, both amused and thoroughly entertained.
Was it the best theatre I'd experienced, no, but as for AmDram, it certainly took this critic's crown.
So, if you fancy being entertained by a delightful story, told with charm by the main cast, I highly recommend you get yourself a seat at the last few performances at the Portscatho Memorial Hall on Wednesday 26th and Thursday 27th August... who knows, you might even see me back for more!
Verdict"A highly enjoyable slice of AmDram." ***
Exhibitions
 Titanic Honour and Glory, The National Maritime Museum,
Falmouth, until 21st June 2009 - If you’re thinking of having a day out from the Roseland, consider paying a visit to the National Maritime Museum in Falmouth – if possible via the charming St Mawes Ferry. A real gem in its own right, the museum is currently host to the fascinating ‘Titanic Honour and Glory’ exhibition – which gives a real insight into the human story behind the sinking of the White Star Line’s most infamous of vessels. Alongside old photos and newspaper articles on the ill-fated ship, the exhibition brings toghether a wide variety of artefacts including crockery, clothes, a teddy bear, letters, and even a passengers pocket watch which stopped working at 2.28am - the time the R.S.S Titanic sank on 15th April 1912.  Some of the objects on display have been lent by Cornish descendants of, or people with a link to, those on board the doomed maiden of the sea and have not been exhibited before – giving the exhibition added poignancy. For further details check out their website at http://www.nmmc.co.uk/ (MB).
|
